Urban News

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Urban Planning

Shops blocked ventilation, made illegal changes

Print PDF

India Express 22.02.2010

Shops blocked ventilation, made illegal changes

Express News Service Tags : borivali fire case Posted: Monday , Feb 22, 2010 at 0407 hrs

Mumbai: Borivali fire ; Civic body to survey old commercial complexes

Shops at Borivali’s Goyal Shopping Centre, which caught fire on Friday, had blocked a mandatory ventilation system located at the basement level, obstructed exit doors and had not installed any sprinkling mechanism. A fire brigade officer was killed in the blaze that took his colleagues almost 12 hours to douse.

The shops had made several structural changes and had allegedly flouted the Development Control regulations, prompting the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation to order a survey of all similar old commercial shopping complexes in the city.

Fire brigade officials said the operation was their toughest in recent times. “The smoke was dense and strong. Non-ventilation and adding a level in the basement with stairs, blocking the exits, made it difficult to take the water line inside,” said chief fire officer Uday Tatkare.

According to firemen, the shops on the ground floor had created two levels with a staircase leading to the basement. “There has to be ventilation at the ground floor level near the ceiling. There was a ventilation grid, but it was obstructed, thus blocking the smoke in small places,” Tatkare said.

Absence of a sprinkler system and closure of exit doors in the basement led them into “a maze of smoke”.

Assistant municipal commissioner, R Central ward, AS Wagralkar said the shopping centre had carried out illegal constructions. “They have also made change of user and action was taken against them under the Maharashtra Region and Town Planning (MRTP) Act.”

The officials said there are several such ground-plus-one and basement-level shops in complexes in Borivali, Kandivli, Malad, Bhuleshwar and Kalbadevi. “We will assess these complexes to verify if any structural changes have been made,” a senior official said.

Cause of death
The postmortem report of 45-year-old fire officer Pradip S Zagde has revealed that he had died of asphyxia, but the report has been sent to the forensic department before formally announcing the cause of death. “There was carbon soot in his respiratory system, but it was less in proportion,” chief fire officer Tatkare said.

Zagde was wearing a breathing apparatus, commissioned in 1998 from Germany, and had been using it for at least 41 minutes till the time of his death. “The cylinder of the apparatus functions for 45 minutes and it sends out an alarm when oxygen is about to get over. Zagde’s apparatus started ringing and perhaps, he had lost his balance and the cupboard fell on him in the panic to get a fresh cylinder. We found him near the exit.”

The fire brigade has around 550 imported breathing apparatus and nearly 225 of them were used on Friday.

Last Updated on Monday, 22 February 2010 11:48
 

Maintenance of the flats is not our business: DDA

Print PDF

Hindustan Times 22.02.2010

Maintenance of the flats is not our business: DDA

“This will collapse if you try driving a small nail in it,” says Shobha Lamba (40), a resident of L1, Kalkaji DDA flats, pointing at the rear wall of a building in this south Delhi neighbourhood.

The wall in question is literally bursting with absorbed seepage.

Swollen on the surface, it’s a wonder how it supports one side of a two-storey building. “The ground floor owner wants the first-floor residents to fix this because it’s their toilet that’s seeping into the wall. It’s been a stalemate.”

If this building falls down crushing a few lives under it, there’s no one residents can blame, certainly not the DDA, which built the colony some 35 years ago.

In its carefully scripted legal deeds, the DDA washes its hands of any responsibility for the construction and upkeep of the buildings once the flats are allotted.

“I have never seen any DDA official visit our colony checking the health of the buildings in the past 35 years,” says Dr RP Sharma (61), president of Kalkaji DDA flats Residents’ Welfare Association (RWA). “Such is the construction quality that I’ve had to renovate every three-four years.”

The flats belong to individual owners, who are supposed to maintain the health of their flats. But who owns the staircases that join all the flats and are used by all? Who should repair the toilet shafts should they develop seepage?

There is no clear answer.

The legalese surrounding the allotment of the flats are such that the DDA is no better than fly by night ‘builders’ who leave flat owners to their fate after their part of the deal is over. The Municipal Corporation of Delhi is in charge of sanitation and upkeep of the parks and the areas.

But the building itself is nobody's baby. Neemo Dhar, DDA spokeswoman simply says, “Once the allottees take possession, the maintenance of the buildings is not our responsibility.”

Kalkaji is just one case in point.

Thousands of residents across DDA colonies, from Dilshad Garden, to Janakpuri and from Munirka to Gulabi Bagh in the North, have been battling this grey area for generations.

“Ground-floor owners don’t want to repair staircases as they don’t climb them,” said AK Oberoi (60), Janakpuri C4-E resident.

The DDA has a simple solution. It assumes residents will sort out “trivial issues” harmoniously. “Residents are to form RWAs, which take care of common-use areas,” Dhar says.

Clearly that has not worked.

The acrimony in among residents is evident in the fact that Kalkaji DDA flats have had a separate RWA of first floor residents since 1989. The repair, renovation or even reincarnation of the flats had depended on its individual owner’s financial expediency.

The DDA couldn’t care less.

Last Updated on Monday, 22 February 2010 10:53
 

Parking confusion

Print PDF

Hindustan Times 22.02.2010

Parking confusion

The ice-cream pushcarts have been moved from there and, from Monday, the car parking lot will also vanish from the stretch.

Delhi Police will no longer allow cars to be parked between Vijay Chowk and India Gate.

But even as the police seem to be on an overdrive to clear the place, New Delhi Municipal Corporation (NDMC) — the civic agency responsible for making parking arrangements in the area — is clueless about the development.

“We have not received any communication so far from Delhi Police,” said Anand Tiwari, spokesperson NDMC.

The civic agency will have to spruce up the area for parking and decide the charges and allot attendants.

Joint Commissioner of Police (Traffic) Satyendra Garg said the police are yet to talk to the NDMC.

“We are going to talk to the land owning agencies and see that the proper parking arrangements are in place. Meanwhile, we will start an education drive to tell people who park their vehicles at Rajpath about the new parking facility near the water channel,” said Garg. “The traffic police personnel will guide people to the new spot and once all the facilities are in place, we will start penalising people.”

He said they were working on a few key points at the new space to be used for parking, including proper lighting, placement of parking attendants and security of the area.

What to expect?

The traffic police will not allow any sort of vehicular parking on the stretch between Vijay Chowk and Rajpath. Some No Parking signs have been placed and the rest will be put up by Monday. Police claimed that this was being done to maintain the “sanctity” of the place.

“We are going to enforce no parking on this stretch from Monday. Traffic police personnel would be placed on the stretch,” said Satyendra Garg, joint commissioner of police (Traffic).

The alternative

Senior traffic police officers said an alternative parking spot has been opened near the water channel at Rajpath.

Till now, the area was only used on Republic Day for parking. “The area would be opened for parking. Some work like providing adequate lighting is to be done but there should be no problem during the day,” said Garg.

Last Updated on Monday, 22 February 2010 10:50
 


Page 253 of 328